Pathology of Compilation of Scientific Articles, One Perspective of Students of Large Universities in Tehran

Document Type : Original Article


1 Assistance Professor, Educational Sciences Department, Literature & Human Sciences Faculty, University of Qom, Qom, Iran.

2 Instructor, Department of management, Payame Noor University (PNU), Isfahan, Iran.


The purpose of this pathological study was to compile scientific articles, which were evaluated through a researcher-made questionnaire on six basic questions. The target population of this study was all postgraduate students of humanities in Tehran, Allameh Tabatabai and Shahid Beheshti Universities (22436). According to Morgan table, 384 students were selected using a convenience sampling electronic questionnaire. A total of 372 valid questionnaires were collected and analyzed. The results show that the situation was not good research ethics and the lack of an ethical code of laws of the country in the form of regulations to promote faculty research and it is fueled largely. Fixing this problem was studied in six areas: The first change in the wrong value system emerged about the role of science and the scientific position, the second attempt to educate students for professional, third: change the rules of the Ministry of Science Thesis, IV: change the simplifying view the domination of science, fifth raise the sensitivity (especially in the scientific community) about the educational impact of unethical behavior and eventually VI: Research ethics charter and designing mechanisms for proper implementation of this.


1. Davari Ardakani, R. (2007/05/05). The illusion of scientific development by increasing the number of articles in the ISI index. Iran Newspaper,3710: 10 (Section Culture and Thought). [In Persian]
2. Dayani, M.H. (2001). Migration of thoughts. Journal of Library and Information Science, 4(1):1-8. [In Persian]
3. Dayani, M.H. (2011). False Evidence in Representing the Growth of Iranian Science. Journal of Library and Information Science. 52:17-29. [In Persian]
4. Debnath, J. & Cariappa, M.P. (2018). Wishing away Plagiarism in Scientific Publications! Will it work? A situational analysis of Plagiarism policy of journals in PubMed. Medical Journal Armed Forces India, 74(2):143–147.
5. Faghihi, A. & Rezaei Manesh, B. (2005). Administrative Ethics. Management Studies in development & Evolution, 47: 25-50. [In Persian]
6. Gharamaleki, A.F. (2004). The Origin of Research Ethics. Mirror of Heritage, 1(27): 7-17. [In Persian]
7. Ghasemi, M. (2006). The evolution of copyright in the international community. Law Journal, 35:147-197. [In Persian]
8. Hakimbashi, H. (2005). Pathology of article writing and research in the religious press. Journal of Research and Hawzah, 23-24: 366-376. [In Persian]
9. Hamner, V. (1992). DO SCIENTISTS NEED A PROFESSIONAL CODE OF ETHICS?. Retrieved from:
10. Hartog, M. & Winstanley,D. (2007). Ethics and Human Resource Management :Professinal Development and Practice. Business and Professional Ethics Journal, 21 (2):3-9.
11. Hasrati, M. (2005). Academic Writing in Iranian University: The Lost Ring of the Chain. IRPHE, 11(1):103-138. [In Persian]
12. Imitation Authorities Comment on Dissertation Copy. News site Alef (2020/03/05) Retrieved from:[In Persian]
13. Khaleghi, N. (2008). Research ethics in the field of social sciences. Ethics in Science and Technology, 3(1-2):83-92. [In Persian]
14. Larijani, B. & Zahedi, F. (2006). A Theory of Ethics Committees in Research in the World and Iran. Iranian Journal of Diabetes and Lipid, (2)1: 281-297. [In Persian]
15. Larijani, B. (2004). A View on Modern Medical Ethics. Research and Hawzah, 17-18:47-59. [In Persian]
16. Lashkarboluki, M. (2008).The Framework for Formulating Professional Values and Ethics for Science and Technology Research. Ethics in Science & Technology, 3(1-2):105-114. [In Persian]
17. Laskar, M. (2017). Publishing articles in scientific journals: a concern for research misconduct or dishonesty (fabrication, falsification and plagiarism). Mediscope, 4(2):1–4.
18. Mirdehghan, M. (2009). Scientific theft; prevention with the growth of education in research structure. Cultural Engineering, 4(33-34):10-17. [In Persian]
19. Moradi Moghadam, H.; Davar panah, M.R. & Dayani, M.H. (2016). The Study of Iran’s Scientific Growth Model after the Islamic Revolution in Iran: Field of Science. Library and Information Science Research (LISRJ), 5(1):28-49. [In Persian]
20. Mousavi, S.R. (2004). Copyright in Islamic Law. Journal of Mashhad Faculty of Theology and Science, 64: 123-166. [In Persian]
21. Naderi, A. (2008). Economics of Education. Tehran: University of Tehran Publications. [In Persian]
22. Naqibzadeh, M.A. (2005). Take a look at the philosophy of education. Tehran:Tahouri Publications. [In Persian]
23. Pellegrini, P.A. (2017). Science as a Matter of Honour: How Accused Scientists Deal with Scientific Fraud in Japan. Science and Engineering Ethics, 24(4): 1297–1313.
24. Piralaei, E. & Sheikhalizadeh, M. (2017). Investigating the Status of Research Ethics in Faculty of Physical Education and Sport Sciences. Bioethics Journal, 7(24): 56-67. [In Persian]
25. Resignation due to scientific theft for doctoral dissertation. News site Alef(2011/03/01), Retrieved from:[In Persian]
26. Safaei Movahhed, S. (2017). Under the Skin of University: Uncovering Academic Exploitation in Iranian Higher Education. Journal of curriculum studies, 8(15):7-34. [In Persian]
27. Sharafi, A. ; Noor Mohammadi, H.A. ; Ebrahimi, R. & Pashang, M.R. (2016). Pathology of Student Research in the Humanities. Information & Communication Quarterly  Book Review, (3)9: 279-304. [In Persian]
28. Sizo, A. ; Lino, A. ; Reis, L.P. & Rocha, Á. (2019). An overview of assessing the quality of peer review reports of scientific articles. International Journal of Information Management, 46:286–293.
29. Vesali, M. (2008). A Study Report on Measuring Adherence to Ethical Behavior among PHD Students in Iran. Tehran: National Science Policy Research Center. [In Persian]
30. Yameni Duzi Sorkhabi, M. ; Khaki Sedigh, A. & Davoodzadeh, A. (2014). Investigating the Status of Research Ethics in Research Experiences of Postgraduate Students of Technical and Engineering Degrees in Tehran State University. Journal of Iranian Higher Education, (6)2: 21-50. [In Persian]
31. Zahedi, L.N. (2007). Misconduct in the Medical Research Process and Article Writing: Professional Responsibility. Ethics in Science and Technology, 2(3- 4): 73-80. [In Persian]